BREAKING NEWS : FORMER POLICE MINISTER BHEKI CELE SLAMS RIAPHIYEGA APPOINTMENT, ALLEGES SABOTAGE INTENT
Former Police Minister Bheki Cele has slammed the appointment of Riah Phiyega as National Police Commissioner in 2012, alleging it was a deliberate attempt to weaken the South African Police Service (SAPS). Speaking today, October 24, 2025, amid ongoing debates about police leadership and effectiveness, Cele didn’t mince words. He served as National Commissioner himself from 2009 to 2011 before misconduct allegations led to his removal, and he’s pointing to questionable appointment practices affecting SAPS top leadership. “I believe the appointment of Riah Phiyega – despite her lacking traditional policing background – indicates an intent to undermine SAPS capabilities,” Cele said in a statement. Phiyega, notable as the first female National Police Commissioner, took office June 12, 2012, under President Jacob Zuma.
There are several controversies surrounding Phiyega’s tenure. Her term faced intense scrutiny after the 2012 Marikana tragedy where 34 protesting miners were killed. The Farlam Commission later recommended investigating her fitness to hold office. Critics, including experts and organisations like Corruption Watch, highlighted Phiyega’s insufficient managerial experience and no police background – echoing concerns about past SAPS leadership appointments. Phiyega was suspended in October 2015 amid fallout from the Marikana inquiry; her tenure ended in 2015/2017 – marred by controversy.
Cele aligns with analyses pointing to serial crises of top management in SAPS linked to problematic appointments. The National Development Plan advocates for transparent, criteria-based selections for police leadership. Over 5.4 million SAPS dockets were closed between 2018-2023 due to insufficient evidence – raising alarms about resources, leadership, and investigative capacities under recent ministers including Cele himself. Experts stress the need for clear appointment criteria to ensure competent, ethical leaders – boosting public trust and SAPS efficacy.
Phiyega had defended her appointment citing corporate leadership experience. She played roles beyond SAPS – restructuring Portnet, leading boards, and committees. Cele is currently testifying before parliament amid other probes; his past includes controversies like “shoot-to-kill” remarks and property deal allegations. The debate underscores critical challenges facing SAPS: leadership integrity, capabilities, and public safety outcomes remain pivotal for South Africa’s security landscape.
See less
